3rd Degree


2010 MLS SuperDraft Defender Rankings

January 12th, 2010 . 9:38 pm . By: Buzz Carrick

Solid year for defenders, with lots of possible guys to choose from.  Center back is a bit thin past the first 5 or 6, but there is a nice group of left backs with potential, although none are locks.  If I have video on a player I will post it below him.

I had about 30 more names I was tracking, but I figure 60 is deep enough.  If someone past this gets picked then my bad.  You’re guy not on here?  Then make your case.

Rank Name School CL HT WT Notes/Comments/Awards
1 Ike Opara Wake Forest Jr 6′2″ 180 Opara has been the best defender in college the last two years.  As a freshman he got into the starting lineup due to a preseason injury to Julian Valentin, when Valentin returned Opara had played so well coach Vidovich scuffled his entire lineup to keep Opara on the field, moving several All-Americans to do so.  Big, strong, fast, and a smart defender; Opara is the complete package.  He’s at least the best defender to leave college since Chad Marshall and might be the best since Eddie Pope.  That is if MLS can land him.  Opara missed seven Wake games this year while starting for the US U20s at the Worlds and was still named ACC Defender time of the Year, for the second time, and consensus 1st Team All-American.  Opara is the #1 prospect on my overall list two years in a row now and he should be #1 overall pick this year.

MLS Combine.

2009: Herman Semi-Finalist, First Team All-American, Soccer American First Team MVP, Top Drawer Soccer First Team, College Soccer News First Team, Goal.com First Team, ACC Defender of the Year, First Team.

2008: Second Team All-American , Soccer American Second Team MVP, College Soccer News First Team, Top Drawer Soccer First Team, ACC Defensive Player of the Year, First Team.

2007: ACC All-Freshman Team

2 Zach Loyd North Carolina Sr. 5′9″ 160 A midfielder or outside back most of his college career, Loyd was forced to move to center back this season because of injuries and excelled in that position.  A First Team All-American and First Team All-ACC, Loyd led the Tar Heel backline to twelve shutouts and only twelve goals allowed all season.  Loyd is an extraordinarily fit and athletic player with a great motor and work rate.  A smart player and tactically flexible, Loyd can play multiple positions although I feel his best position and future as a pro is in midfield (even though I left him with the defenders), which just happens to be where MLS listed him for the combine.  At 5′9″ he’s probably a bit short to play center back for most MLS coaches.

MLS Combine

2009: Herman Semi-Finalist, Soccer American First Team MVP, First Team All-American, College Soccer News First Team, Goal.com Third Team, ACC First Team

Started 15 games for the Tar Heels…scored two goals and had as many assists (through 11/29) for six points…anchored a North Carolina defense that posted 11 shutouts and allowed only 11 goals (0.52 per game) all season…an All-ACC first-team selection despite playing center back for the first time in his career due to injuries on the team.

3 Kwame Watson-Siriboe UConn Sr 6′3″ 196 The massive Watson-Siriboe (6′3″, 196 lbs) dominated play in the Big East this year with UConn to earn the Big East Co-Defender of the Year nod.  A former US U18, Watson-Siriboe broke out in 2007 for UConn and might be ranked higher on this list if not for missing half of 2008 with injury.  The UConn back line allowed only 10 goals in 19 games this season while posting 13 shutouts.  His superlative senior season should be enough to erase any injury concerns.  Watson-Siriboe has pace to go with his size, making him very tough to beat.MLS Combine

2009: Top Drawer Soccer First Team, College Soccer News First Team, goal.om First Team, Big East Co-Defender of the Year, First Team

US U18

4 Sheanon Williams UNC So 5′11″ 170 Has not signed with MLS and is probably not eligible to be drafted.

Theoretically only a sophomore, Williams left UNC after his outstanding freshman year to focus on the US U20 team in hopes of signing a professional contract.  The somewhat disappointing US performance at the Worlds may have hampered his status as Williams remains “unattached” to any pro club despite trials in Europe.  MLS rules can be a bit ambiguous, but having sat out a season Williams should be able to sign with MLS as a free agent after the MLS SuperDraft if he doesn’t sign a Generation adidas deal in advance.  A outside back with terrific pace, Williams can both defend and get forward to create havoc.  Williams is also a former US U17 residency player and he did play some PDL soccer with the Carolina Dynamo this last summer.

2008: Top Drawer Soccer All-Rookie Second team, ACC All-Freshman Team. Soccer America All-Freshman Team.

US U17, U20

FC Greater Boston Bolts

5 Nick Cardenas San Diego St Sr 6′5″ 205 The towering (6′5″) Cardenas was effective at both ends of the pitch for the Aztecs, leaving SDSU with 12 goals and 7 assists.  A four time Pac-10 honoree, including Pac 10 Freshman of the Year in 2006, Cardenas has excelled against heavyweight competition week in and week out and is capable of shutting down an offense.  A former US U20 call up, Cardenas has been involved in 21 shutouts in his college career.

MLS Combine

2009: Pac 10 First Team.

2008: Pac 10 Second Team.

2007: Pac 10 Second Team.

2006: Pac 10 Freshman of the Year, Second Team

12g, 7a career

6 Phil Edginton Louisville Sr 6′3″ 190 Another big (6′3″) center back out of the Big East, Edginton was named Big East Co-Defensive Player of the Year and was a unanimous selection to the 2009 All-Big East First Team.  He led the Cardinal D to 13 shutouts in 20 games giving up only 12 goals all year.  Edginton can provide a little something going forward as well as he grabbed two goals and two assists this season.  Recently called to the New Zealand senior national team, Edginton is a former Kiwi U20, U16, and U14.

MLS Combine

2009: Second Team All-American , Soccer American Second Team MVP, Top Drawer Soccer Second Team, College Soccer News Third Team,  Goal.com Second Team, Big East Co-Defender of the Year, First Team (Unam).

2007: Big East Third Team

7 Zachery Herold US U17 HS 5′11″ 160 MLS Combine.  West Pines United FC. Linked to  FC Koln.
8 Chris Schuler Creighton Sr 6′4″ 185 The first of two good defenders coming out of Creighton this year, Schuler is an intimidator and dominate physical presence in the back for the Bluejays.  Schuler helped Creighton to eight shutouts this year, a school record thirteen last year, and thirty-nine in his career.  A top ten prospect out of high school, Schuler was red-shirted at Indiana in 2005 before transferring to Creighton.  Despite his size and power, 6 foot 4, 185 pounds, Schuler plays a disciplined game earning very few yellow cards.

MLS Combine 2009: MVC First Team.  2008: Second Team All-American , Top Drawer Soccer Third Team, College Soccer News Second Team, MVC Defensive Player of the Year, First Team.  2007: MVC First Team  Indiana transfer

The 6-foot-4 center back was dominant this fall, helping the Bluejay defense log a school-record 13 shutouts. A Bluejay captain, he anchored the back line to a 0.48 goals against average while starting every match and leading the team by playing 1,852 of the possible 1,864 minutes during his junior season.

9 Barry Rice Kentucky Sr 5′11″ 180 A tremendous athlete, Rice is the best player every produced by the University of Kentucky.  Back to back Conference USA Defensive Player of the Year nods in 2007 and 2008, followed up with an All-American award in 2009.  “Only” 5′11″  but blessed with a tremendous vertical, Kentucky added a stat to their game tracking just for Rice, headers contested/won.  Over ‘08 and 09′ Rice won an astounding 315 of the 373 headers he contested, roughly 84%.  Rice can get forward dangerously too, he leaves UK with twelve goals and seven assists.  He was also recently named one of 15 players on the ESPN High School All-Decade Team for leading St. Ignatius to back to back Ohio state titles.

2009: Second Team All-American , College Soccer News Third Team, Goal.com Third Team, Conference USA First Team.

2008: College Soccer News Second Team, Top Drawer Soccer Third Team, Conference USA Defensive Player of the Year, First Team.

2007: Top Drawer Soccer Second Team, Conference USA Defender of the Year, First Team.

2006: Conference USA All-Freshman Team

Combine Nominee

10 Kevin Tangney Maryland Sr. 6′2″ 169 10 MLS Combine 2009: ACC Second Team 2007: missed for injury, ACL.  2006: medical red shirt Acl tear
11 Justin Morrow Notre Dame Sr 5′8″ 160 MLS Combine 2009: Big East Second TeamLeft back, post combine best Left back on list

189

218

12 Mark Blades Northwestern Sr 5′6″ 150 2009: AA Second Team, Top Drawer Soccer Second Team, College Soccer News Second Team, Goal.com Second Team, Big Ten Co-Defender of the Year, First Team (Unam).  2008: Third Team All-American , Soccer American Second Team MVP, Big Ten Second Team. 2007: Big Ten Second Team.  2006: Big Ten FTLeft back

Combine Nominee

13 Seth Sinovic Creighton Sr. 5′9″ 165 The other top notch defender out of Creighton this season is the lefty, left back Seth Sinovic.  Selected to the MLS Combine last year, the red-shirt senior Sinovic made the decision to pull out of the event and return for a final year with the Bluejays.  Granted a hardship year by the NCAA, Sinovic had an outstanding season being named to his second straight All-MVC First Team, his third conference nod in four seasons.  A defender capable of shutting down an opposition player one v one, Sinivic also contributed going forward tying for the Creighton lead in assists with six in 2008, then grabbing three goals and four assists this season to finish second on the team scoring charts.

MLS Combine.

2009: MVC First Team.

2008: MVC First Team.

2007: MVC Second Team.

14 Ryan Peterman San Diego Sr 5′11″ 165 West Coast Conference Player of he Year as a left back is a nice feat to pull off.  Peterman was also WCC First Team in 2008 and All-Rookie Team back in 2006.  Peterman likes the ball at his feet and relishes taking players on the dribble.  He was a marked man in 2009, literally, as some teams tried to counter him with a marking forward.  Peterman has a really nice left foot and is the kind of two way player that should excel in MLS.

MLS Combine

2009: Third Team All-American , Top Drawer Soccer Third Team, West Coast Conference Player of the Year, First Team.  2008: West Coast Conference First Team

Left back

15 Kris Banghart Denver Sr 6′1″ 188 MLS Combine2009: MPSF First Team.

2008: MPSF Second Team.

2007: MPSF Second Team.

2006:  North Carolina Wesleyan

US U20

16 Nick Barclay Gonzaga Sr 5′10″ 2009: West Coast Conference Second Team.2008: Top Drawer Soccer Third Team, West Coast Conference First Team, Defensive Player of the Year

Combine Nominee

17 Ofori Sarkodie Indiana Sr 5′10″ 178 MLS Combine2009: Big East Second Team

2007: Big Ten First Team.

2006: Big Ten FT An exceptionally gifted athlete that played centrally on the US Youth teams, but is a bit on the short side and will likely play wide in MLS.  He wanted to sign out of U17 residency but on the advice of MLS coaches, notably Sigi Schmid, he went to college for two seaJrns.  US U17 residency and US U20.

2005 NSCAA National Youth player of the Year.

US U17, U20 pool

18 Tim Ream St Louis SR 6′1″ 160 MLS Combine2009: All-American Third Team, Top Drawer Soccer Honorable Mention, College Soccer News Second Team, Atlantic 10 Defensive Player of the Year, First Team.

2007: Atlantic 10 Second Team

Left back

19 Kevin Gallaugher Cal-St Dominguez Hills Sr 6′2″ 190 2009: NSCAA D2 Player of the Year, First Team All-American.2008: Colonial Athletic Association Male Athlete of the Year, NSCAA D2 Player of the Year, NSCAA First TeamAA, CCAA Defensive MVP & First Team, national champs.

2007: Third Team All-American, CCAA First Team & Newcomer of the Year.

2006: Rondo JC team MVP.

Gallaugher becomes the only Division II men’s soccer player to win multiple Player of the Year honors since the award was first bestowed in 1996, and only the second D-II player to ever win multiple Player of the Year awards after Christian Brothers University’s Missy Gregg claimed back-to-back women’s soccer Player of the Year honors in 2001 and 2002.

20 Doug Verhoff Ohio State Sr 6′0″ 170 2009: College Soccer News Third Team, Top Drawer Soccer Third Team, Big Ten Co-Defender of the Year, First Team (Unam)Combine Nominee
21 Joel Gustafsson St John’s Sr 6′3″ 185 2009: Big East Second Team.2008: Second Team All-American, Top Drawer Soccer First Team, College Soccer News First Team, Big East Defensive Player of the Year, First Team. 2

007: Big East Honorable Mention

22 Richard Martinez Hofstra Sr 5′9″ 160 2009: Colonial Athletic Association Defensive Player of the Year,  First Team.2008: Colonial Athletic Association First Team.

2007: Colonial Athletic Association Second Team.  2006: Colonial Athletic Association  All-Rookie Team

Martinez, who also plays for the Puerto Rico national team, started every game in his four seasons at Hofstra except for his debut as a freshman, when he came off the bench.

23 Julien Edwards Drake Sr. 6′0″ MLS Combine2009: MVC First Team.

2008: MVC First Team

Canadian

24 Steven Kinney Elon Sr 6′0″ 175 10 MLS Combine2009: Southern Conference First Team.

2008: Southern Conference First Team. 2

007: SC First Team

25 Tyler Barry California Sr 6′0″ 165 MLS Combine2008: Tore ACL still Pac 10 Second Team.

2007: Pac 10 Honorable Mention.

Barry, who completed his college career with the 2008 season, suffered an anterior cruciate ligament knee injury midway through 2008 and was not a viable candidate to attend the 2008 MLS Combine.

26 Tennant McVea Loyola Sr 6′3″ 105 10 MLS Combine add on2009: MAAC Defensive Player of the Year, First Team.

2008: First Team All-American, CAN Third Team, MAAC Defensive Player of the Year, First Team.

2007: MAAC Defensive Player of the Year

27 Daniel Bostock Monmouth Sr 6′3″ 190 2009: AA Second Team, NEC & ECAC Defensive Player of the Year, First Team.2008: NEC First Team.

2007: NEC Second Team.

2006: Virginia Intermont College

English CB

Bostock, who was also named the NEC and ECAC Defensive Player of the Year, helped lead a MU defensive unit that led the nation in goals against average with 0.45 tallies allowed per game and rank second in the nation in team save percentage (.891).

Combine Nominee

28 Joe Annese New Hampshire Sr 6′2″ 175 2009: American East Defender of the Year & First Team.Annese played in 16 games, including 14 starts, tallying two goals on six shots this season.  Offense aside, he also proved to be a defensive catalyst, helping the ‘Cats post a goals against average of 0.57 and three shutouts in America East play, both top honors within the conference.
29 Nick Schuerman Wofford Sr 6′0″ 170 2009: Third Team All-American , Southern Conference First Team. 5 goals.2007: nissed half year wit injury

center back, 4 year starter

Schuermann, a defenseman from Fort Mill, S.C., started all 18 games and scored five goals on the season. He had a hat-trick at Furman on November 3, the ninth in school history. He has started all 65 games in his career and has seven goals with one assist.

Combine Nominee

30 Dustin Dawes Marshall Sr 6′2″ 165 2009: Conference USA First Team.  Led Conference-USA in game-winning goals with four2008: Led the Thundering Herd in goals (4) and points (10) in his first season at Marshall.

2006: Louisville

31 Chad Borak Cal State Northridge Sr 6′0″ 165 MLS Combine2009: Big West First Team
32 Simon Ejdemyr New Mexico Sr 6′5″ 205 2009: MPSF First Team.2008: MPSF First Team.

2007: MPSF First Team

2006: MPSF First Team.

Swedish

Combine Nominee

33 Adam Welch Lehigh Sr 6′0″ 155 MLS Combine2009: Patriot League Defender of the Year, First Team,  played half year at forward scored 5 goals.
34 Martin Hedevag UC Santa Barbara Sr 6′2″ 200 MLS Combine2009: Big West Defensive Player of the Year, First Team

Gothenburg, Sweden

35 David Newton Clemson Sr-r 6′4″ 215 2008: ACC Second Team2005: redshirt

Combine Nominee

36 Tyler Ruthven South Carolina Sr 6′2″ 183 2009: Conference USA First Team.2008: Conference USA Second Team.

2007: Conference USA Newcomer of the Year, Third Team.

2006: transfer from San Francisco

Combine Nominee

37 Kwaku Nyamekye Harvard Sr 6′1″ 200 MLS Combine2009: Ivy First Team.

2008: Ivy First Team.

2007: Ivy Second Team.

2006: Ivy Honorable Mention.

38 Korede Aiyegbusi North Carolina State Sr 5′5″ 155 10 MLS CombineEnglish, Left back

Played the last two years at Essex Community College in Maryland … Named a NJCAA Second-Team All-American in 2007 … A first-team all-conference selection in both 2006 and 2007

39 Ben Clark St John’s SR 5′7″ 160 MLS Combine2009: Big East Second Team
40 Kevin Santora UC Irvine Sr 5′11″ 150 2009: Big West First Team
41 Johannes Demarzi Missouri State Sr. 5′8″ 2009: MVC First Team.2008: MVC Second Team moved to D.

2007: striker 20 starts, 2nd in scoring.

CS Northridge 06-05.  Redshirt in 05.

Combine Nominee

42 Kwaku Nyamekye Harvard Sr 6′1″ 200 2009: Ivy First Team (unam).2008: Ivy First Team.

2007: Ivy Second Team

2006: Honorable Mention Ivy.

center back, Swiss.

Combine Nominee

43 Pat Selwood Bucknell Sr 2009: Patroit League First Team.2008: Patroit League Second Team.

He was named MVP of the Patriot League Tournament after leading the team to back-to-back 1-0 wins over Lafayette and American. In fact, Bucknell broke the school record for shutouts in a season with 12, with 10 of those coming by 1-0 margins.

Selwood missed only one start in his last two seasons and was the leader of Bucknell’s defense from his center back position. Selwood anchored a standout defense that had allowed only 17 goals in its first 22 games before conceding five to No. 2 Virginia in the NCAA Round of 32. Selwood was named to all-tournament teams in each of the five tournaments in which Bucknell played over the last two years, including the Nike Fall Classic, the Mayor’s Cup and the Patriot League Tournament this season.

44 Taylor Waspi Wisconsin Sr 6′0″ 185 2009: Wisconsin leading scorer with 3 goals 1 ast.2008: Big Ten Second Team.
45 Grant Campbell Bradley Sr. 5′9″ 157 2009: MVC Second Team.2008: MVC First Team.

Midfielder in 06-07.

2007: MVC Honorable Mention.

2006: MVC Second Team.

Chicago Fire Premier in 2009,

Campbell becomes the fifth player in school history to earn all-conference recognition four times in his career.

446 Martin Vickerton Longwood Sr 5′11″ 2009:  Atlantic Soccer Conference Second Team.2008:  Atlantic Soccer Conference First Team twice NE region team.

LM/Left back, English, 4 year starter

Combine Nominee

47 Jonathan Collier Furman Sr 5′11″ 165 2009: Southern Conference Second Team.2008: Southern Conference Second Team.

06-07 at Virginia Tech

lefty

A recipient of the Southern Conference’s prestigious Coleman Lew Leadership Award,

Combine Nominee

48 Eric Conklin Wisconsin Sr-r 6′0″ 175 2008: Big Ten First Team.2006: Big Ten All-Freshman Team
49 Robert Hodge Stetson Sr 6′2″ 170 2009:  A-Sun Defensive Player of the Year, First Team.2008: A-Sun First Team

2007:  A-Sun Second Team. 2

006:  A-Sun All-Freshman Team.

England

Hodge, a senior defender out of Devon, England is the first Hatter ever to be named A-Sun Defensive Player of the Year. The Stetson team captain anchored the backline that led the conference in goals against. He started all 16 games he appeared in this season at center back

50 Len Coleman Georgetown Sr 6′4″ 220 2008: Big East Third Team  2007: Big East Third TeamCB

4 year starter

Combine Nominee

51 Ryan Handbury Dayton SR 6′0″ 2009: Atlantic 10 First Team, 8 ast.2006: Atlantic 10 Honorable Mention.

4 year starter, English

Combine Nominee

52 Anthony Matos St Francis SR 6′2″ 190 2009: NEC First Team.2006: NEC Second Team.

center back

Combine Nominee

53 Michael Erwood Furman Sr 6′2″ 175 2008: lost half season with knee injury.lefty, Combine Nominee
54 David Reed St John’s SR 5′8″ 170 Left back, 3 year starter, Combine Nominee
55 Machel James Oakland Sr 5′11″ 165 2009: Summit League First Team.2008: Summit League Second Team but injured.

RB, Trinidad, 3 year starter

James and Hildebrandt both led a defensive effort that only allowed 11 goals this season, the lowest in the league, and only two against Summit League opponents.

Combine Nominee

56 Tim Grey San Diego Sr 6′1″ 180 2009: West Coast Conference Honorable Mentioncenter back, 4 year starter

Combine Nominee

57 Zach Tierney Illinois Chicago Sr 6′1″ 175 2008: only played 12 games due to injury.  transfer from new Mexico2007: MPSF First Team.

2006: MPSF Second Team led lobos with 5 ast.

Combine Nominee

58 Liam Carson SUNY Binghamton Sr 6′0″ 190 2009: American East First Team.2008: medical redshirt

Scotland

Carson missed last season with an injury but has returned this season as the team captain and has anchored the Bearcat backline. He has paced a defense that ranks second in the conference with 0.98 GAA and has recorded five shutouts.

59 Cedomir Tomcic Hartford Sr 6′5″ 215 2009: American East First Team.Serbian, Transferred to Hartford after playing two seasons at Mid-Continent University

Tomcic has been an anchor on the Hawks’ back line, helping the Hartford defense post four shutouts this season and 12 total over his two-year career.

60 Oscar Monjaras San Jose St Sr 5′10″ 156 2009: MPSF First Team.Played a large role in directing a young Spartan back line that lost its other three starting members to graduation, to seven shutouts on the year.
61 David Lozano UC Riverside Sr 6′1″ 165 2009: Big West Second Team.2008: Big West First Team.

2007: Big West Second Team.

2005: medical redshirt for Cal State LA

Lozano broke the Highlanders career record for matches played this year and finished his four-year UCR career with 71 matches played, 61 starts and one assist from his defender slot.






5 Comments

  1. Comment by GY on January 12, 2010 10:47 PM

    Hedevag all the way at 34?! He was BW Defender of the Year and you have him at 34? I know he didn’t have a great combine b/c of injury and stomach flu, but I would think he is higher that that. He’s also more of a utility player and has good skill up top as a target striker.

  2. Comment by Buzz Carrick on January 12, 2010 11:06 PM

    He dropped from the combine performance. But he’s also low because he really had one strong season combined with not being a domestic player.

  3. Comment by KMJvet on January 13, 2010 8:48 PM

    Would a team drafting Sheanon Williams be taking a big risk that he does not wish to sign with MLS?

  4. Comment by Buzz Carrick on January 13, 2010 8:57 PM

    I don’t think he’s even draftable, I left him in cause he’s sat out a year and has been wanting to sign with someone.

  5. Comment by 3nOut on January 13, 2010 10:32 PM

    the more i hear/read about watson sirboe, the more i’m liking him w/ one of our 5-6 picks. would that be too high for him? would that be a good use of our pick?

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a comment

© Copyright 1996-2009 A. Buzz Carrick, All Rights Reserved. This website is an unofficial and independently-operated source of soccer news and information and is not directly affiliated with or endorsed by any team, league or their owners. Logos and other promotional materials are property of their respective owners. For FC Dallas' official team site, visit www.fcdallas.net. Interested in contributing to our effort? Then contact us at buzz@3rddegree.net

    Founded October 1997

    Volume Fourteen

  • 42 Point Playoff Target

  • Current Points: 21
    Points Out: 21
    Games Left: 17