Practice Observations: A New Method
May 20th, 2009 . 5:06 pm . By: Buzz Carrick
Such a nice day today that I broke out the Jeep again. This is the strangest spring, but I do love this cooler weather we’ve had this year. I’d probably trade the nice temps for a FCD winning record though. This is a lot more fun when the Red Stripes are good. News, Notes and Observations- No sign of Dario Sala, George John or Steve Purdy outside. All are rehabbing somewhere. Sala should be about two weeks out from return. Purdy two weeks as well perhaps. John will be closer to a month it sounds like. - Jeff Cunningham comes out and does some ropes type stuff with one of the trainers. So he might be a week out or so. - “Tom” Sanchez is bring a little more intensity today, I won’t be shocked if Sanchez makes his debut this week, probably off the bench for Rocha, Ferreira, or one of the strikers. He did a little extra explosiveness work along with Torres and Saragosa using one of the elastic rope belts. - Kenny Cooper and Peri Marosevic last two out today. - Kyle Davies continues to impress me with his soccer brain, self belief, and toughness. I’m not going to call for him to start yet, but damn if it’s not close. He really does a lot of directing of traffic and will stand up to a vet player if he think he’s right. The kids got some huevos. - With a 24 man roster and three injuries there aren’t enough players to go 11v11. Hyndman says with the five U20s leaving FCD will be inviting some local younger players to join in training. Some will be college, and I would image some will be USL, PDL, of even FCD Juniors. Joe Cooper, Kenny’s younger brother who is at SMU, will be one of them according to Hyndman. Some invitees will even start coming out tomorrow. - I wouldn’t mind seeing Leone Cruz and Paulo da Silva from SMU either. And while I’m doing the picking, let’s see Austin Neil the Conference USA Freshman of the Year for Tulsa too. He scored 11 goals as a freshman, which is a impressive total. - Ellinger told me Oscar Pareja in fact will be putting on the cleats to join in training tomorrow. - In case you missed it, Break Shea and Josh Lambo have been pulled from the U20s. Catching Up with Schellas HyndmanLooks like you’re sticking with the 3-5-2?
Buzz’s Coach Speak Translator: The 3-5-2 worked didn’t it? In a 3-5-2 you don’t really have the wingbacks in Rocha and van den Bergh, so what do you do there?
Buzz’s Coach Speak Translator: Hop. That’s what we do. Hope. You tend to not work the upcoming starters during the early part of the week, perhaps even making the starting decision quite late. Can you talk about why you wait so late in the week to work the starting line up?
Buzz’s Coach Speak Translator: There is a method to my madness. You may not like it, but there is a reason for all things. TrainingOut of warm up and stretching the team is put into a possession kind of game with neutral players on each side and in each corner of a 30×30 yard box. Red: Wallace, Rocha, McCarty, vdBergh, Dello-Russo, Shea Second session was a box to box game, Since there aren’t enough players both teams play missing wide mids. Hyndman makes a small box of red cones at midfield that limits the central midfielders. You can see it’s a 3-5-2 though for the first team against a 4-4-2. Green: Cooper, Shea, Ferreira, Guarda, Saragosa, Torres, Ricchetti, Moor, Burse VDBergh and Avila start out watching. Drill version 2.0 has them both in with the grey for Sanchez and McCarty. Version 3.0 McCarty replaces Saragosa on the first team and Sanchez is in for Ferreira. Version 4.0 Rocha comes in for Guarda making the midfield McCarty, Rocha, Sanchez on the first team. Lineup PredictionOk so 3-5-2 it is. I’m a bit surprised Hyndman isn’t going back his beloved diamond 4-4-2. But you know how he is about trust and with the injuries in the back line this appears to be the lien up that gets the most trusted players on the field. Ricchetti is the middle of the back line with Moor and Torres. Saragosa and Guarda in the middle, although I for one would like McCarty over Saragosa. In this system Saragosa is the pure holder, and Guarda the more linking type player. VDB and Rocha stay out there but the wide mids will be early subs probably. What kind of player might depend on the score. Shea keeps his spot with Cooper by both injury and game.
Thought of the DayI’m not sold on this idea of a 3-5-2. I don’t think this shape fits this team any better than the diamond 4-4-2 did. In the Diamond 4 FCD was missing the rangy, hard tackling holding mid (like Osvaldo Alonso or Ricardo Clark, the only guy they have close is probably Anthony Wallace)… and a right mid… and a center back (is Ricchetti solving that?). In the 3-5-2 FCD is missing the wingbacks. Against Wallace is the closest on the left, but there isn’t anyone on the right. My favorite personal shape is a flat four, jut watch Man U if you want to see one. But that’s not right either for FCD, where do you put Farreira in that shape and there is still no right mid? Really some kind of 4-3-3- is probably the best shape with this team. Which isn’t shocking cause that’s how Morrow had transitioned the roster. (I won’t bother breaking it down cause it won’t happen here anyway.) Point being, until Hyndman gets another transfer window, heck maybe even two, the roster just isn’t going to fit the shape he wants. This isn’t Europe with 40 man rosters where you can play whatever you want when you want. In MLS you have to build a roster to fit the shape you want to play. One could of course adapt the shape to what is best at the moment and work towards the desired shape as the roster changes. But that doesn’t seem to be the way for this coach. 11 Comments Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI Leave a comment | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

Great work as always Buzz. As a curiosity thing, does FCD run film sessions with the team to prep for a game at all, or is that mainly a coaches’ thing?
And as for a holding mid, you think we could land Barry Ferguson (or would Dallas want him)?
Morrow transitioned to the 4-3-3 after he transitioned to the 4-4-2 and then he transitioned to the 3-4-3…..what formation DIDN’T he try? The problem with the 4-3-3 then, as it would be now, is the inability for a three man midfield to win the battles in this league. They’ll give up possession and have three advanced attackers who will spend the majority of the game waiting to get involved.
Morrow transitioned to the 4-3-3 after he transitioned to the 4-4-2 and then he transitioned to the 3-4-3…..what formation DIDN’T he try? The problem with the 4-3-3 then, as it would be now, is the inability for a three man midfield to win the battles in this league. They’ll give up possession and have three advanced attackers who will spend the majority of the game waiting to get involved.
P.S. – Sorry, forgot to tell you great post!
This was supposed to be an attacking juggernaut of a team with an OK defense. Now all of the attackers are on the bench, being pulled back, or are not performing. Not good.
As fate would have it, I’d be west of Seattle when we played the Sounders (traded in my seats for two on the side of me against Columbus). Is it worth my time to watch the game? Gaffer made it sound like “no”.
Buzz, If I m not mistake, Paulo is already is Brazil so he couldnt be a guest player.
I would like to see Ferreira up top instead of shea and dax in place of shea playing the cam
Moose, skip the first 30 but after that worth watching.
Aaron, Fugerson is probably a bit old to cover the ground needed.
The hope has to be that the players go rogue and play their own way. Hyndman, god love him, is not equal to the task. I’ve been on the fence with him for a while, not wishing to dogpile, but Hyndman is not up to the challenge.
Hyndman doesn’t know what he’s doing.
I’ll continue to hope for FCD losses until he’s sacked and out of the league for good.
Now “H” is playing the 3-5-2 that Clarke played and he thought was so bad when he took over.
I hope FC Dallas continues to believe in the youth. See great examples in Atlas of Mexico. Please become the the birthright of the US youth and not only have them but start playing them. Good luck!
Juan, that is actually funny. Last year Morrow was rebuilding with youth, explained it to the FO and got fired when the team played made youthful mistakes and got hammered by the Galaxy. FCD is on the old Rangers bizarro track where every year or two they veer one way then a completely opposite way. The Rangers have stayed on their youth mission for about three years now and are starting to see good results.
buzz,
think SH could use Pitch right about now? methinks so!!!
Also, i know you’ve been clamoring for years that a 3-5-2 is the perfect formation for FCD to play, but you seem to veer from that in this report. is that because of the current personnel? do you believe (like me) that the 3-5-2 is a good fit as the general identity of the club because it clogs the midfield, making it tough for visiting teams to play in Dallas in July & August?