Practice Observations: The Rose Goes in the Front

Wednesday, October 1st, 2008, 9:00 AM, PHP Stadium

October 1st, 2008 . By: Buzz Carrick

“You don’t **** with a winning streak” - Crash Davis

Holy cow is it October already?  Dang it this time of year goes fast.  Sometimes having to work for a living stinks.

At least the weather is terrific, albeit kinda warm for what I think of as October weather.  Mid 70s during training. We’re in the main stadium, it’s quite a bit warmer in there as the breeze is blocked by the press box and stands.  Training is not particularly long nor intense, as it’s a pre-game walk through.

News, Notes, & Observations

- Jeff Rowland has torn his meniscus and he’s done for the year.  This will be his third or fourth knee operation he’s had.  He works hard and has a solid head for the game, but with that kind of record for injury he might as well move on to another career.

- Brek Shea has his meniscus operation a while ago, but I had been meaning to ask Schellas what kind he had.  Being a young kid they opted for the repair kind, which means 4 to 6 months recovery, but a far better long term benefit.

- Compare that to Sikora who had his meniscus removed, he’s back in 5 weeks.  But the long term won’t be as good.  He’s also had a procedure or two on his meniscus before in his career so there wasn’t much use in the repair idea.  Looking at him run today I don’t see 100% from him as he’s still got a tiny hitch in his giddy up.  But Schellas wants some time for him prior to the playoffs, so look for Victor off the bench very soon.

- Schellas says he’s talked to Wagenfuhr one time since he took over, which should tell you how far off David is from any possible return.  He won’t be back this year and I don’t expect him next year.

- Emerson Hyndman Watch: he’s here but doesn’t participate in any drills.

Catching up with Schellas Hyndman

I’ve come to the conclusion that Coach Hyndman is the longest winded, most verbose coach in the history of sport.  Just look at how long these answers are.  I’m going to have to start cutting him down.

(p.s. Don’t let it slip your mind that the coach speak translations are a bit.)

What do you think has contributed to this run of good results?

I think firstly that the ball is bouncing right for us.  Maybe in the past it hasn’t been bouncing right for us.  People are being dragged out of position, we’re getting good service in there.  Then I would hope that it’s the structure.  People having understanding of their roles, whether they cross, whether they shoot.

I had an interesting conversation I had with my three strikes in DC.  I brought them into a room just before I took them out to the field and said, “guys, the last time we played DC I thought we had to many unselfish players, people trying to make the pass.  What I want you to think about is, that word is never going to be used again.  Unselfish player is not going to be used again.  It’s going to be,  if you have the best chance to score, shoot.  If you don’t have the best chance, then give it to a teammates.  But don’t feel like you have to give it to a teammate because you don’t want the responsibility to shoot.” I think they feel more comfortable with that, so they’re going at it.

We’ve had some good free kicks, Andre [Rocha] has done some good things for us with the free kick.  Chicago was an early goal that he hit and it goes in from his free kick, that’s what I mean by the ball bouncing right.

I think part of our attack is our new found counter attack.  Where, again, players are on the same page.  We have a direction where we want to win the ball, what we do when we win the ball, how we play out, and players are buying into it cause they are starting to see the success.

Buzz’s Coach Speak Translator:  Luck, skill, and coaching.

You’ve said Pitchkolan has been playing well, so why put Davino back in for him?

I was just talking with the team, and I said, “you know, in all the years I’ve coached I’ve always thought the hardest thing I’ve had to do was drop a player from the team.  Hardest thing to do is cut a player.”  Here’s a college kid who wants to play the sport but his lifestyle is screwed up.  He’s a party animal, chasing women, he’s not going to classes.  So you eventually get tired of that high maintenance and you drop him for his own good.

In a professional game it’s not that kind of situation.  You move them along to some place else or whatever.  But I think the hardest thing to do is take a player out of the starting line up that’s been playing so well for you.  For another player you have higher expectations, you know his level of play is going to be better.  What goes through my mind is if you put our defenders, and  I’m making a statement here, Adrian [Serioux], [Aaron] Pitch[kolan], Drew [Moor], and Blake [Wagner], and you put all their experience together in one bottle, it may not fill as much as Duilio’s experiences.

So I’m making a decision on a very experienced player that I think can help get this team get to the playoffs, realizing I’m really effecting a player who is for whatever, six or seven games, been a starter and done everything that I’ve asked him to do.  Tough decision for us.

So that’s the hard thing for me, the hardest thing for me, to go to a player and say you’re not going to be playing even though you ;ve done everything I’ve asked you to do.  I just have a stronger belief as a coach that that player is a better player and may make a difference.

Buzz’s Coach Speak Translator:  Experience.

Putting Davino back in against the taboo of changing a winning team, clearly are comfortable with that?

I wouldn’t make that decision if I wasn’t comfortable. You’re right, there are a lot of complications with this whole thing.  Not only is it the right decision? How do you effect the guy you’re taking out?  How do you effect his friends and teammates who believe in him?  That’s why it was very important to have a team conversation.  This was not an easy decision.

I said it earlier, “players win games, coaches lose games.”  If we don’t win this game it’s going to be a coaches problem, “why did he put Duilio?”  That’s my decision and my decisions will always be the best for the team.

Buzz’s Coach Speak Translator:  If we lose this game it’s on me.

Training

After some warm up jogging, stretching, and some simple cone work, Schellas moves the team straight into the walk through.  Pretty obvious what the lineup will be.

After the walk through is some work on corners.  Rocha takes them for the first team and McCarty for the second.  Pitch and Davino take turns with the first team.

Lastly is everyone’s favorite, the shooting gallery drill. 5v5 or 6v6 with the rest on each offensive end. Young versus Old.

Green (young): Wileman, Cooper, Wallace, Dello-Russo, McCarty, Moor, Wagner, Avila, Wadsworth, Guarda, Daniels.
Gray (old): Sikora, Oduro, Serioux, Rhine, Saragosa, Pitchkolan, Cunningham, Ricchetti, Davino, Watson, Rocha.

Not sure how Watson and Rocha ended up on old since they are both younger than half the young team.

Lineup Prediction

When you outscore your opposition 7 to 1 in the previous two games you don’t change anything.  Except of course that Schellas is changing something: Davino in for Pitchkolan

Cooper Cunningham
Guarda
Saragosa Ricchetti Rocha
Wagner Davino Moor Serioux
Sala

If San Jose wins this game, the Davino/Pitch swap will come under massive criticism and Schellas knows it.

Thought of the Day

There are a couple schools of thought about a situation like the Davino/Pitchkolan one.

1. You can’t lose your place via injury.  So Davino deserves his spot back.

2. You can lose your spot when your replacement plays terrific.  So Pitch keeps the spot.

3. You don’t change the team when they are winning.  Particularly when it’s a 7 to 1 in two games.  Pitch stays in there.

4. The better player plays and Davino is the better player.  So Davino plays.

So which one do you believe?





22 Comments

  1. Comment by jordan =) on October 1, 2008 3:01 pm

    PITCH SHOULD PLAY!

  2. Comment by J on October 1, 2008 3:04 pm

    “4. The better player plays and Davino is the better player. So Davino plays.”

    Boy, and I mean this in all seriousness, but is Davino the better player, right now? Career wise, he wins hands down. But I think in his time at FCD he has been exposed regularly. There is no way he is in top shape or form right now, and they are going against a team with Huckerby, Alvarez and Sealy playing as a “strike force”, all of whom can kill him for speed. SH is right, if they lose this game, he is on the hook. I would still like to see Davino get more reserve time in before throwing him back into the starting lineup.

  3. Comment by D on October 1, 2008 3:05 pm

    Very tough decision. Fortunately inserting a different center back is not quite as difficult as say an attacking midfielder. Davino was playing at his best level of the season before his injury so it’s up to the coach to determine if he’s back at that level now. I trust Schellas to be able to determine that Davino is at 100%….let’s go FCD!

  4. Comment by Aljarov on October 1, 2008 4:37 pm

    I don’t know if Schellas is being gutsy or stupid on this…the other coaches have opted to keep the winning sides together at the expense of the bigger names. (Gomez in COL)

    I guess if they win he looks like the genius, they lose and he looks like an idiot out of his depth….

    time will tell.

  5. Comment by Pegasus on October 1, 2008 4:47 pm

    It seemed Moor was playing left center back and Pitch was right. If they allign like you have it it is really sort of two switches. Could Moor be better at LCB than RCB? If not it doesn’t matter.

  6. Comment by Buzz Carrick on October 1, 2008 5:00 pm

    Peg, Schellas seems to put the most experienced CB on the side with Wagner.

  7. Comment by James on October 1, 2008 5:46 pm

    If this team is going to get to the playoffs and do anything when they get there, then they will need Davino’s experience.

    Hate to say it because Pitch has played really well, but the guy was our captain for most of the year for a reason.

  8. Comment by nutella on October 1, 2008 6:02 pm

    5. Money, money, money!!!!!!

    (Davino plays)

  9. Comment by tater on October 1, 2008 6:24 pm

    Play Pitch, sell Davino to the DFW tornados.

  10. Comment by BN on October 1, 2008 7:00 pm

    doesn’t the 12 year old go to school?

  11. Comment by Moose McDowell on October 1, 2008 7:02 pm

    I really hope this is a great game for us - this is a very hungry team we’re facing.

    If Davino gets burned on Thursday (which I hope doesn’t happen and that Coach is right), we’ve got two possible chants:

    1. Sub-In-Pitch! (The most likely)
    2. 4-Hundred-K! (If it happens more than once)

    Can’t wait for tomorrow. Go Hoops!

  12. Comment by cm on October 1, 2008 7:24 pm

    I know I sound like a broken record (think of a skipping cd for you young folk) but once again I will voice my opinion anyway and say that I a) believe Dax should be starting b) feel awful for him and c) will miss him greatly.

  13. Comment by Fred on October 1, 2008 8:14 pm

    Sort of reminiscent of the US Women’s team former caoch April H. taking out Hope Solo for
    Brianna Scurry when Bri hadn’t played for awhile. Pitch needs to play, the back four need to stay the same. Davino can be a sub and hopefully keep Bruno company on the bench (my wish)

  14. Comment by phil on October 1, 2008 8:18 pm

    I would like to keep Pitch in, so my best guess would be to move Serioux to the left, moor to the right and have davino and pitch on the middle since Wagner is not a starter class player anyways…

  15. Comment by the other alex on October 1, 2008 8:47 pm

    Fred: that was Greg Ryan and it cost him his job.
    Last time SH changed the team after a 2 game winning streak they lost. Look for the same result tomorrow.

  16. Comment by Steve on October 2, 2008 4:47 am

    Move Moor wide and bench Wagner

  17. Comment by peter on October 2, 2008 4:57 am

    It’s it that Pitch deserves to start or are we really afraid of just how bad Davino is? Yes, it’s Davino that sucks and Pitch has been acceptable. SH must go!

  18. Comment by Pony2 on October 2, 2008 7:38 am

    it’s sh’s decision so lets see what happens and then if it works out we can say we agreed. If dav gets burned we can say it was a bad idea! :idea:

  19. Comment by spotbeam29 on October 2, 2008 8:04 am

    …. Coop … Jeff C.

    Avila … Guarda … Dax

    ……… Ser/ioux/agosa …….

    Moor … Pitch … Richetti … Rocha

    or the back 5 could re-arrange:
    …….. Richetti ……………
    Serioux .. Moor . Pitch … Rocha

    LB stays home, RB (Rocha) overlaps all day. Darn. Forgot about SJ’s lefty is Darren Huckerby. Oh well. mebbe Rocha at RB is for a different opponenet.

  20. Comment by RodneyMunch on October 2, 2008 8:36 am

    Davino sucks! Let Pitch play!

  21. Comment by Jamie Fougerousse on October 2, 2008 11:39 am

    Play Pitch. Davino deserves respect but that does not mean he has any business starting right now.

  22. Comment by twotone on October 2, 2008 1:13 pm

    the big diff between the Women’s Nats Scurry/Solo deal was that Scurry had been healthy the entire time and Hope Solo was THE #1 keeper when Ryan made his switch.

    Wasnt the 12 yr old going to go to Newcastle and stay in their Academy? what ever happened with that?

    I agree……Dax should be starting now. Until Sikora gets back 100%

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a comment

© Copyright 1996-2007 A. Buzz Carrick, All Rights Reserved. This website is an unofficial and independently-operated source of soccer news and information and is not directly affiliated with or endorsed by any team, league or their owners. Logos and other promotional materials are property of their respective owners. For FC Dallas' official team site, visit www.fcdallas.net. Interested in contributing to our effort? Then contact us at buzz@3rddegree.net